Group Policy Preferences - Registry Items

 

Specifically focusing on the type of Action that can be selected, and the difference between Update and Replace. Microsoft has the following references to this topic. However, to make it clear the following tests several scenarios under a Replace action compared to an Update action:

Scenario: New registry item defined for HKLM\Software\Newkey. DWORD registry item defined here called NewItem1, with a value of 1.

The Newkey folder does not exist to begin with.

Test	Update	Replace
NewItem1 = 1 defined in GPO.	Registry key and value created in registry	Registry key and value created in registry
Manually add new items into registry under Newkey.	After GPO refresh they remain.	After GPO refresh they remain.
Update GPO so that NewItem1 = 2	Registry updated as well.	Registry updated as well.
Delete NewItem1 from registry.	GPO puts it back.	GPO puts it back.
Manually change NewItem1 = 5 in registry.	GPO changes it back to 2.	GPO changes it back to 2.
Rename NewItem1 to NewItem2 in registry.	GPO creates NewItem1 again, leaving NewItem2 in place.	GPO creates NewItem1 again, leaving NewItem2 in place.
Rename NewItem1 to NewItem5 in GPO.	New item created in registry so that both NewItem1 and NewItem5 are present.	NewItem1 is renamed to NewItem5 in the registry as well.
Delete NewItem1 registry item from the GPO.	Remains in registry.	Deleted from registry.